Justia Family Law Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in South Dakota Supreme Court
Interest Of P.R.M.
A four-year-old child was repeatedly found outside alone and unsupervised, sometimes in dangerous situations. On multiple occasions, law enforcement and Child Protective Services (CPS) intervened due to reports of neglect by both parents. CPS substantiated several neglect allegations, including incidents where the child was left outside without proper clothing and where the father locked the mother and child in their apartment. The child exhibited developmental delays and behavioral issues, and there were additional reports of domestic abuse and possible sexual abuse. Following these events, the child was ultimately placed in CPS custody and later in a treatment facility.The Circuit Court of the Second Judicial Circuit, Minnehaha County, South Dakota, became involved after the State filed an abuse and neglect petition. Both parents stipulated that the child was abused or neglected, and the court entered an adjudication accordingly. When the State moved to terminate parental rights, the proceedings were delayed because the father’s first court-appointed attorney withdrew due to threatening messages from the father. A substitute attorney was appointed, but the father’s aggressive and threatening behavior toward this attorney led to a second withdrawal. The court then appointed the substitute attorney as standby counsel and warned the father that further misconduct would require him to represent himself. The dispositional hearing proceeded with the father representing himself with the support of standby counsel. The court ultimately terminated both parents’ parental rights after finding ongoing neglect, substance abuse, and failure to address mental health concerns.The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed whether the circuit court erred by failing to appoint a third attorney for the father at the dispositional hearing. The Supreme Court held that a parent’s right to counsel in parental rights termination proceedings, both statutory and under due process, can be waived by the parent’s misconduct after clear warning. The court affirmed the circuit court’s decision. View "Interest Of P.R.M." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, South Dakota Supreme Court
Interest Of A.l.
A mother with a lengthy history of drug use, trafficking, and prior child welfare involvement was incarcerated in federal prison after being convicted for conspiracy to possess and distribute controlled substances. Her two minor children, D.L. and A.L., were initially placed with their father. After the children later disclosed abuse and neglect in their father's home, the Department of Social Services removed them and placed them in foster and institutional care.The Circuit Court of the Second Judicial Circuit, Minnehaha County, South Dakota, oversaw abuse and neglect proceedings. Both parents stipulated that the children lacked proper parental care. The mother participated in hearings by video conference from prison. During the case, the mother filed three motions for compassionate release from federal custody, arguing that her early release would allow her to reunite with her children and avoid termination of her parental rights. While her first two motions for compassionate release were denied, her third remained pending at the time of the final dispositional hearing. The circuit court denied her requests for a continuance, emphasizing the children's need for stability and the uncertainty of the compassionate release proceedings. The court terminated both parents' rights, finding that the state had met its burden under the Indian Child Welfare Act and that termination was in the children’s best interests.The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed only whether the circuit court abused its discretion in denying the mother’s continuance requests based on her pending compassionate release motion. The Supreme Court declined to take judicial notice of the subsequent federal order granting compassionate release, as it was outside the appellate record and occurred after the termination decision. The Supreme Court held that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion in denying the continuance, emphasizing the children’s need for permanency and the speculative nature of the mother’s potential release. The decision of the circuit court was affirmed. View "Interest Of A.l." on Justia Law
Shevling v. Major
A married couple, both active-duty military members, separated after nearly two decades of marriage and executed a notarized separation agreement in 2020 while stationed in Okinawa. The agreement provided that the wife would receive $1,500 per month in maintenance until divorce, 20% of the husband’s military retirement pay upon his retirement, and be named as beneficiary of his Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP). The wife later initiated a divorce in South Dakota, and the parties submitted a stipulation and settlement agreement incorporating key provisions from their separation. The divorce decree was filed in February 2021. Over time, the husband failed to make some required maintenance payments and, after retiring, did not pay the wife her portion of his retirement nor complete the SBP paperwork. The wife sought contempt and modifications, while the husband argued compliance was impossible due to deficiencies in the decree.The Circuit Court of the First Judicial Circuit, Charles Mix County, declined to hold the husband in contempt, finding the divorce decree’s orders too vague for enforcement. The court denied modification of the property division, found no fraud or coercion, and refused to vacate the decree. It reduced the wife’s retirement share from 20% to 16.1% using a coverture formula, ordered payment of $5,000 in arrears plus 8% interest, and instructed the husband to effectuate the SBP. Both parties appealed.The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota affirmed in part and reversed in part. It held that reducing the wife’s retirement share below the agreed 20% was error, as was applying an 8% rather than the statutory 10% interest rate to arrears. The court remanded for correction of those issues, but affirmed the denial of contempt, refusal to vacate the decree, and the exclusion of additional payments for stimulus or tax refunds. The court also found no due process violations or abuse of discretion in declining to take sworn testimony. View "Shevling v. Major" on Justia Law
Bryant v. Bryant
Jay Bryant initiated an action to partition a 40-acre parcel of land, originally conveyed in 1978 to his parents, Lenora and Paul Bryant, as joint tenants. Upon their divorce in 1991, a property settlement stipulated that Paul would receive the parcel as his own, and Lenora would receive a different property. Although the divorce decree incorporated this agreement, Lenora never deeded her interest in the 40 acres to Paul. Paul subsequently transferred his interest to a third party, who then conveyed the property to Jay and his brother Jed. After Paul’s death in 2021 and during probate, a title report revealed that Lenora still legally owned an undivided one-half interest in the property.The Circuit Court of the Fourth Judicial Circuit, Meade County, allowed Jay to amend his complaint to add Lenora and bifurcated the quiet title and partition actions. At trial, the court took judicial notice of the divorce file and stipulation and reviewed the chain of warranty deeds. After considering testimony and evidence, the circuit court found that Jay and Jed had a legal interest in the property and that Lenora’s claim was inconsistent with her prior agreement. The court applied judicial estoppel to preclude Lenora from asserting a continuing interest, extinguished her claim, and quieted title in favor of Jay and Jed. The court issued a final judgment on the quiet title action under SDCL 15-6-54(b).The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed the appeal. It held that Jay had standing under SDCL 21-41-1 to pursue a quiet title action and that the claim was not barred by the 20-year statute of limitations in SDCL 15-2-6. The Court affirmed the circuit court’s application of judicial estoppel, concluding Lenora was precluded from asserting an ownership interest after accepting the benefits of the stipulated property settlement. The circuit court’s judgment quieting title in favor of Jay and Jed was affirmed. View "Bryant v. Bryant" on Justia Law
Estate Of Webb
A businessman and rancher in South Dakota, after dating a Colorado horse breeder for nearly a year, proposed marriage. Shortly before the wedding, he presented her with a prenuptial agreement drafted by his attorney. The agreement waived her right to any share of his estate after his death. The parties signed the agreement at the attorney’s office minutes before their civil ceremony. They were later married in Italy and had two children. The businessman died approximately eight years later. The surviving spouse then petitioned for an elective share of the estate and a family allowance, claiming her signature on the agreement was involuntary and the agreement was unconscionable.The Fourth Judicial Circuit Court of Dewey County, South Dakota, held a trial on her petition. The court granted her request for a family allowance but denied her petition for an elective share. The court found she voluntarily signed the agreement and that it was not unconscionable, emphasizing her education, business experience, and opportunity to review the agreement or consult independent counsel. The court also found that the financial disclosures provided were fair and reasonable, and that the terms of the agreement, including a provision for her in the event of divorce, were not disproportionate or unjust. Stephanie appealed the denial of her elective share.The Supreme Court of South Dakota reviewed the case and affirmed the lower court’s decision. The Court held that the prenuptial agreement was voluntarily executed and was not unconscionable under South Dakota law. It found no clear error in the circuit court’s factual findings and determined that the financial disclosure and circumstances surrounding execution of the agreement satisfied statutory requirements. The Supreme Court affirmed the validity and enforceability of the prenuptial agreement and the waiver of the elective share. View "Estate Of Webb" on Justia Law
Jessop v. Combs
Brian Jessop and Lisa Combs are the parents of a young child, B.J.J. After their relationship ended, Lisa moved with B.J.J. from Utah to Rapid City, South Dakota. Brian filed a petition seeking parenting time consistent with the South Dakota Parenting Guidelines, while Lisa opposed unsupervised visitation and requested sole custody and only supervised contact for Brian, citing concerns about his alleged ties to the Fundamentalist Church of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS) and claims of past abuse. Throughout the proceedings, Lisa maintained that Brian’s involvement with the FLDS posed risks to B.J.J., and she also alleged that Brian had raped her, resulting in the child’s conception. Brian denied the allegations of abuse and FLDS involvement, asserting that he had left the church years earlier.The custody matter was heard in the Circuit Court of the Seventh Judicial Circuit, Pennington County, South Dakota. Prior to trial, Lisa unsuccessfully sought a continuance due to an unavailable witness and later moved to exclude rebuttal testimony from Brian’s wife, which was also denied. After a bench trial, the circuit court rejected Lisa’s rape allegations and found insufficient evidence that Brian was a current member or follower of the FLDS. The custody evaluator recommended primary physical custody to Lisa but supported unsupervised visitation for Brian. The court awarded joint legal custody, primary physical custody to Lisa, and unsupervised parenting time to Brian, following the Parenting Guidelines.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota affirmed the circuit court’s rulings. The Supreme Court held that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion in denying Lisa’s motions for continuance and exclusion of rebuttal testimony, nor did it err in its findings regarding Brian’s lack of FLDS involvement and the rape allegation. The Supreme Court also affirmed the denial of Lisa’s request for attorney fees and declined to award appellate attorney fees. View "Jessop v. Combs" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, South Dakota Supreme Court
King v. King
A married couple with two minor children experienced significant changes in their financial and professional circumstances during their marriage. The husband started several businesses, including an insurance agency and other ventures with local investors. In early 2023, he faced serious legal and regulatory issues, including a large default judgment and revocation of his insurance and gaming licenses, followed by criminal indictments. Amid these developments, the wife discovered evidence of his extramarital affair and initiated divorce proceedings, seeking an equitable division of marital property and debts. During the divorce, the husband retained counsel and used marital funds to commence a lawsuit against his former business partners to recover money he had invested in their shared businesses.The divorce case was tried in the Circuit Court of the Second Judicial Circuit, Lincoln County, South Dakota. Both parties disputed the classification and valuation of assets, notably the pending lawsuit. The husband argued that the lawsuit should be treated as his separate property due to an alleged pretrial agreement. The wife disputed the existence of such an agreement and asserted that the lawsuit was a marital asset. The circuit court found no binding agreement on the lawsuit’s classification, treated the pending lawsuit as marital property, valued it at $350,000 based on the invested retainer and a percentage of the claimed amount, and assigned it to the husband.The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed the case. It held that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion in classifying the pending lawsuit as marital property subject to equitable division. The Supreme Court found that the valuation of the lawsuit was not clearly erroneous, as it reasonably reflected the evidence presented at trial. The Supreme Court affirmed the circuit court’s decisions regarding classification and valuation, and granted the wife’s request for appellate attorney fees. View "King v. King" on Justia Law
Trumble v. Trumble
A married couple owned a waterfront property in Canada, which was destroyed by fire during their divorce proceedings. The wife, who was living at the Canadian property, disclosed during discovery that there was a single insurance policy with a $2 million Canadian Dollar (CAD) limit covering the property. The parties entered into a stipulation and agreement, incorporated into the divorce decree, which awarded the wife the Canadian property and the related insurance proceeds. Several months later, the husband learned that the wife was actually receiving $4 million CAD in insurance proceeds, not the $2 million CAD previously disclosed. He alleged that the wife had concealed an additional insurance policy and sought relief from the divorce judgment on grounds of fraud.The Circuit Court of the Second Judicial Circuit, Minnehaha County, South Dakota, reviewed the husband’s motion for relief under SDCL 15-6-60(b)(3). After a hearing based on affidavits and documentary evidence, the court found that the wife had committed fraud by intentionally concealing the additional insurance policy. The court ordered the wife to produce all insurance policies in effect at the time of the fire and directed that any insurance proceeds exceeding $2 million CAD be split equally between the parties, in accordance with their agreement and SDCL 25-4-77. The court also awarded attorney fees to the husband and issued a stay allowing the wife to use the insurance proceeds to rebuild the property, with any excess to be held in trust.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota held that the circuit court’s finding of fraud was not clearly erroneous and affirmed the grant of Rule 60(b) relief. The Supreme Court remanded the case for further proceedings to determine the appropriate division of assets under the current circumstances, given the stay and use of insurance proceeds for reconstruction. The Supreme Court also awarded appellate attorney fees to the husband. View "Trumble v. Trumble" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, South Dakota Supreme Court
Peery v. Peery
A couple divorced in 2019, with the husband required to pay monthly alimony to the wife under the terms of their agreement. After the sale of the marital home, the husband’s alimony obligation was set at $13,500 per month. In 2023, the husband relocated to Texas, left his previous employment, and experienced a significant decrease in income. He struggled to meet his alimony obligations, missing several payments, and ultimately sought a reduction in his alimony due to his changed financial circumstances. The wife, whose dental hygiene license had lapsed and who was not employed, relied primarily on alimony for her income and filed a motion for contempt based on the missed payments.The Circuit Court of the Second Judicial Circuit, Lincoln County, South Dakota, reviewed the parties’ motions. After considering testimony and financial documentation, the court found the husband’s account of his reduced income credible and determined that his move and employment changes were not made in bad faith or to avoid alimony. The court also found that the wife’s claimed financial needs were not fully credible, noting that some expenses were inflated or related to adult children. The court reduced the husband’s alimony obligation to $6,000 per month effective January 1, 2025, denied the wife’s contempt motion, and declined to make the modification retroactive, reasoning that the wife should have time to adjust to the reduced payments.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota affirmed the circuit court’s decisions. The Supreme Court held that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion in modifying the alimony obligation, did not clearly err in denying the contempt motion, and did not abuse its discretion in refusing to apply the modification retroactively. The court’s findings were supported by the evidence and were within the permissible range of judicial decisions. View "Peery v. Peery" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, South Dakota Supreme Court
Melius v. Songer
A child, B.M., was born to Cheryl Melius and Lakota Songer, who were no longer in a relationship at the time of birth. Cheryl initially had sole custody and did not inform Lakota of the birth immediately. After B.M. was diagnosed with failure to thrive, Cheryl voluntarily placed the child with her brother, Miles, and his wife, Tori (the Meliuses), who were later granted guardianship. Lakota established paternity and sought custody, but the Meliuses initiated a third-party custody action, leading to a combined proceeding. During the litigation, the Meliuses were granted temporary custody, and Lakota was given stepped-up visitation. The Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) was found to apply after Lakota disclosed his tribal status.The Circuit Court of the Sixth Judicial Circuit, Gregory County, South Dakota, held a trial and found that while the Meliuses had a significant relationship with B.M., they failed to prove by clear and convincing evidence that extraordinary circumstances existed to rebut Lakota’s presumptive right to custody under SDCL 25-5-30. The court awarded Lakota sole custody but granted the Meliuses ongoing visitation and ordered Lakota to use a specific daycare provider. The court also assessed attorney fees against Lakota for his late disclosure of tribal status and for contempt related to violating court orders.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota affirmed the lower court’s finding that the Meliuses did not establish extraordinary circumstances to overcome Lakota’s parental rights and affirmed the denial of non-parent custody. The Supreme Court reversed the award of permanent visitation to the Meliuses, holding that such visitation cannot be granted absent a finding of extraordinary circumstances rebutting the parent’s rights. The Court also reversed the attorney fees related to the tribal status delay, finding the lower court erred in assigning responsibility to Lakota. The issue regarding the daycare provider was deemed moot. The case was remanded to determine attorney fees solely attributable to contempt. View "Melius v. Songer" on Justia Law