Stephanie W. v. Maxwell V.

Maxwell V. sued for custody of Terrance, the son he had with Stephanie W. The superior court granted him primary physical custody and joint legal custody. The Supreme Court reviewed and affirmed the first custody order in most respects, but remanded on two custody factors. On remand, the superior court again granted Maxwell primary physical custody. Stephanie appealed the second custody order. Two of her arguments, relating to discovery, were not preserved for appeal, were forfeited, and did not constitute plain error. The Supreme Court concluded Stephanie's third argument failed on the merits. She also challenged the superior court’s determination of two custody factors in light of the Supreme Court's remand instructions in first custody proceeding, arguing that the superior court abused its discretion by failing to consider Maxwell’s child support arrears in its stability determination, and that the superior court abused its discretion by holding against her, in the continuing-relationship determination, her allegations that Maxwell was manufacturing methamphetamine with Terrance present. The Supreme Court rejected Stephanie's additional arguments and affirmed the superior court's order in all respects. View "Stephanie W. v. Maxwell V." on Justia Law