Justia Family Law Opinion Summaries
Kelly R. v. State
This case involves the placement of a child, Sunny, who was taken into custody by the Alaska Office of Children’s Services (OCS) after being found in her mother’s care with signs of drug exposure. Sunny was initially placed with unrelated foster parents. Her biological sister, Brianna, had previously been placed with and adopted by Kelly and Brian Randall, who reside in Tennessee. OCS considered placing Sunny with the Randalls, facilitating visits to prepare for a possible transfer, but Sunny’s mother and current foster parents opposed this move.The Superior Court for the Third Judicial District, Palmer, held a placement review hearing after Sunny’s mother requested one, and Kelly Randall filed a proxy petition for Sunny’s adoption. The court denied both the proposed transfer to the Randalls and Kelly’s adoption petition, finding by clear and convincing evidence that relocating Sunny to Tennessee would be contrary to her best interests. Importantly, the court declined to apply the statutory presumption under AS 47.10.080(w) that maintaining a sibling relationship is in the child’s best interest, reasoning that no such relationship existed between Sunny and Brianna due to their separate upbringing. When Kelly requested another placement review hearing, OCS and the court relied on the prior findings and again denied the request.On appeal, the Supreme Court of Alaska reviewed the denial of Kelly’s placement request and consolidated appeals. The court held that the statutory presumption favoring maintenance of sibling relationships applies to siblings related by blood, regardless of whether legal ties have been severed by adoption or whether an emotional or social relationship exists. The Supreme Court found that the superior court erred by not applying this presumption in its assessment of good cause to deviate from statutory placement preferences. The order denying Kelly’s request was vacated and the matter remanded for further proceedings. View "Kelly R. v. State" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Alaska Supreme Court, Family Law
Bowen v. Ray
A married couple with four children separated in March 2022, and the wife filed for divorce in May 2022. During the proceedings, the husband, a pediatric dentist and National Guard member, submitted financial documents significantly understating his income. Based on his reported income, the Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Palmer, issued an interim child support order requiring him to pay $697.94 per month. The wife later presented evidence showing the husband earned substantially more than reported, including a new position with a $176,000 salary and additional income streams.After a motion to vacate the original child support order, supported by documentary evidence of the husband’s true income, the superior court issued a new order increasing the monthly obligation to $3,780, retroactive to the month the husband began his higher-paying job. The husband challenged this as an impermissible retroactive modification under Alaska Civil Rule 90.3(h) and argued that the evidence regarding his income and the division of equity in a property titled to his parents was insufficient. The superior court found the husband’s testimony and supporting documents established that his income exceeded the cap for child support calculations. Furthermore, the court found that the couple had acquired an equity interest in the property known as Silver Springs, based on evidence that the husband made monthly payments to his parents with the intention of eventual ownership, making the equity marital property subject to division.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska held that Civil Rule 90.3 does not shield a parent who knowingly underreports income from a retroactive increase in support obligations. The court affirmed the superior court’s findings regarding both the child support calculation and the marital estate’s equity interest in the Silver Springs property, upholding the rulings in all respects. View "Bowen v. Ray" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Alaska Supreme Court, Family Law
Jonah O. v. State
An infant, identified as an Indian child due to his mother’s tribal affiliation, was placed by his mother with a relative, also an Indian person, who acted as the child’s primary caregiver for several years. The child’s father was uninvolved, incarcerated, and lacked a relationship with the child. After reports of neglect and abuse by the relative surfaced, the Office of Children’s Services (OCS) and the Village tribal authority removed the child from the relative’s care. OCS initially considered returning the child to the mother but found her circumstances unsuitable and subsequently assumed emergency custody. The Tribe intervened in the child in need of aid proceedings. The superior court eventually placed the child in the mother’s care under OCS supervision, later returned him to foster care, and OCS petitioned to terminate parental rights.The Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Anchorage, handled the child in need of aid proceedings. The relative, claiming status as an Indian custodian under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), requested party status and court-appointed counsel. The superior court initially found that any Indian custodianship had dissolved once the child was returned to the mother. The relative appealed, and the Alaska Supreme Court remanded the case for the purpose of allowing the relative to intervene. On remand, the superior court allowed intervention, but the father, who retained residual parental rights, moved to revoke the Indian custodianship.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed the appeal. It held that a parent with residual rights may revoke an Indian custodianship established by temporary transfer, even over the objection of the parent who created the custodianship. The court affirmed the superior court’s order, finding no error in recognizing the father’s revocation of the Indian custodianship and denying the relative ongoing party status as Indian custodian. View "Jonah O. v. State" on Justia Law
Kursave v. Van Der Mescht
After the end of a romantic relationship between two individuals, the petitioner sought a domestic abuse protection order against the respondent. The petitioner alleged that the respondent engaged in unwanted and alarming conduct, including appearing uninvited at her home, attempting to contact her through multiple channels after she had blocked him, and making a surprise visit to her workplace with gifts shortly after the breakup. The petitioner claimed these actions made her feel unsafe and amounted to stalking and harassment.The matter was initially heard in the Circuit Court of the Seventh Judicial Circuit in Custer County, South Dakota. At the hearing, both parties testified and presented their accounts of the events. The court found portions of both parties’ testimony credible but ultimately determined that the respondent had not engaged in a pattern of harassing or threatening behavior as defined by law. Specifically, the court found no “course of conduct” sufficient to constitute stalking and noted the significant time gaps between incidents. The court found the respondent credible regarding his intentions and concluded he did not act with the intent to harass. The petition for a permanent protection order was denied, though the respondent was warned against future contact.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed whether the circuit court’s findings were clearly erroneous and whether denying the protection order was an abuse of discretion. The Supreme Court held that, although the circuit court erred in determining the parties had not been in a significant romantic relationship within the statutory period, it did not clearly err in finding that the respondent’s conduct did not amount to stalking or domestic abuse under South Dakota law. The Supreme Court affirmed the circuit court’s denial of the permanent protection order. View "Kursave v. Van Der Mescht" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, South Dakota Supreme Court
Roundtree v. Roanoke City Dept. of Social Services
A mother, Cheyenne Roundtree, is the biological parent of a nonverbal child diagnosed with autism. Over several years, the Roanoke City Department of Social Services (RDSS) was involved with the family due to repeated incidents of domestic violence, which the child witnessed, and allegations of physical abuse. After a violent domestic disturbance in November 2021, the child was placed in foster care. Though the child was briefly returned to Roundtree, further allegations of abuse led to renewed removal and RDSS custody. A foster care plan was implemented that required Roundtree to improve her parenting skills, complete counseling and educational programs, and demonstrate stability in housing and employment. Despite receiving services for over a year, RDSS determined that Roundtree had not met the plan’s requirements, particularly in her ability to parent a child with autism and manage her own mental health needs.The Roanoke City Juvenile & Domestic Relations Court terminated Roundtree’s parental rights and approved a new foster care plan with the goal of adoption. Roundtree appealed to the Circuit Court for the City of Roanoke, which held a trial. The court found that, while there was insufficient evidence for termination under Code § 16.1-283(B), Roundtree had failed to substantially remedy the conditions requiring her child’s continued foster care under Code § 16.1-283(C)(2). The court concluded she was unable to meet her daughter’s needs and approved the foster care plan.Upon further appeal, the Court of Appeals of Virginia affirmed the circuit court’s decision. The Supreme Court of Virginia found no error in the lower courts’ judgments. The Supreme Court held that, under Code § 16.1-283(C)(2), the termination of Roundtree’s parental rights and approval of the foster care plan for adoption were supported by clear and convincing evidence and were in the child’s best interests. The judgment of the Court of Appeals was affirmed. View "Roundtree v. Roanoke City Dept. of Social Services" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Supreme Court of Virginia
S.L. v. A.C.
Following the divorce of a mother and father in West Virginia in 2019, their agreed parenting plan allowed the father regular visitation with their young child, B.L. In July 2021, the mother sought a domestic violence protection order after B.L., then three years old, disclosed sexual abuse by the father both to her and in a Child Advocacy Center interview. The mother subsequently petitioned for modification of parenting time, alleging further disclosures and physical injuries upon B.L.’s return from the father's care. Investigations by Virginia’s child protective agencies determined the allegations were “unfounded,” but the mother and B.L.’s therapist continued to report concerns, leading to additional forensic interviews and referrals.The Family Court of Wayne County initially suspended the father’s visitation and appointed a guardian ad litem for B.L. After hearings in 2024, the court found by a preponderance of the evidence that the father sexually abused B.L., citing consistent disclosures in interviews and therapy, and awarded sole custody and exclusive decision-making authority to the mother, denying the father any parenting time. The father appealed, arguing the evidence was insufficient and highlighting the “unfounded” findings by Virginia agencies.The Intermediate Court of Appeals of West Virginia affirmed the family court’s decision, determining there was substantial evidence supporting the finding of abuse and that the family court did not err or abuse its discretion.Upon further appeal, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia affirmed the Intermediate Court's ruling, holding that the family court’s findings were not clearly erroneous and its application of law was not an abuse of discretion. The Supreme Court also remanded the case in part, instructing the family court to comply with Rule 48, which requires mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse to Child Protective Services and the circuit court, regardless of prior investigations or jurisdiction. View "S.L. v. A.C." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
In re J.N.N.
After a district court terminated a mother's parental rights to her two children, the mother appealed the decision. The essential facts of the case are not disputed, and they were adequately summarized by the Kansas Court of Appeals. The district court found, by clear and convincing evidence, that the mother was unfit under several statutory factors, that her unfitness was unlikely to change in the foreseeable future, and that terminating her rights was in the best interests of the children.The Kansas Court of Appeals reviewed the district court’s decision and affirmed it. The appellate panel concluded that the record supported the district court’s findings regarding the mother's unfitness, the unlikelihood of change, and the children’s best interests. The mother sought further review, focusing her challenge on the finding regarding foreseeability—that her unfitness was unlikely to change in the foreseeable future.The Supreme Court of the State of Kansas granted discretionary review based on a summary petition under Supreme Court Rule 8.03A, which allows for summary consideration only if controlling authority is dispositive of the entire appeal or no substantial question is presented. Upon review, the Supreme Court determined that the requirements for summary review were not met because no controlling Kansas authority dictated a different result, and the issues raised involved questions of substance. The court clarified that Rule 8.03A is not intended for full review of evidentiary sufficiency arguments and declined to consider arguments not properly presented through the summary petition mechanism. The Supreme Court dismissed the summary petition for review as improvidently granted, leaving the Court of Appeals' decision affirming the district court’s termination of parental rights undisturbed. View "In re J.N.N.
" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Kansas Supreme Court
State v. Jackson
Clarence Jackson was convicted for assault causing bodily injury after he struck eight-year-old W.W. several times with a leather belt while visiting the child’s home. Jackson, who is the father of three of W.W.’s half-siblings, occasionally visited the home but never lived there and had no formal custody or visitation arrangement. On the day of the incident, Jackson arrived unannounced, directed W.W. to clean his room, and, after a dispute, retrieved a belt from his car and hit the child. The episode was recorded by W.W.’s sister and reported to authorities. W.W. sustained bruises that were visible for several days.The Iowa District Court for Buchanan County, sitting in a bench trial, convicted Jackson. The court found that the corporal punishment defense did not apply because Jackson was not W.W.’s parent and, even if it did, his actions were unreasonable and abusive rather than corrective. Jackson appealed, challenging the application of the corporal punishment defense and the reasonableness determination. The Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction, concluding that Jackson’s use of corporal punishment was unreasonable and declining to address whether the defense applies to nonparents.The Iowa Supreme Court reviewed only Jackson’s sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenge regarding the corporal punishment defense. The court held that Jackson’s conduct was not protected by the corporal punishment defense because the child’s mother did not authorize him to use a belt and did not place the child in his care at the time of the incident. The court further held that Jackson did not have sufficient care, custody, and control of W.W. to trigger the defense, and, even assuming the defense could apply, Jackson’s conduct was unreasonable under Iowa law. The court affirmed the decisions of the lower courts. View "State v. Jackson" on Justia Law
In re A.S.
The case involves two parents whose children were removed from their home after allegations of truancy, poor living conditions, physical abuse, and felony child abuse charges. After an unsuccessful improvement period, the parents stipulated to certain allegations and were adjudicated as abusive and neglectful. The circuit court initially granted them post-adjudicatory improvement periods, but they failed to comply with requirements, tested positive for cocaine, and missed a status hearing. Their improvement periods were terminated, and at the dispositional hearing, although there were motions to terminate parental rights, the court decided it was not in the children's best interests to do so. Instead, the children were placed in the temporary custody of the Department of Human Services (DHS), with limited visitation granted to the parents.Subsequently, the parents and their counsel did not participate in several permanency review hearings due to confusion about their roles and responsibilities after the initial disposition. Notices were inconsistently sent, and the parents were functionally excluded from key proceedings, including multi-disciplinary team meetings and decisions about visitation, which was eventually discontinued. The guardian ad litem later moved to modify disposition and terminate parental rights. The circuit court "reappointed" counsel and held a contested hearing where the parents argued they had not received proper notice. The court found a material change in circumstances and terminated parental rights, reasoning that the children no longer wished to be reunified and had bonded with their foster family.The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia reviewed the case. It held that the circuit court substantially disregarded statutory and procedural requirements by functionally excluding the parents and failing to make the statutory findings necessary for termination of parental rights under West Virginia Code § 49-4-604(c)(6). The court vacated the order terminating parental rights and remanded for further proceedings consistent with statutory and procedural requirements. View "In re A.S." on Justia Law
In re A.C.
A petition was filed against a mother after she failed to follow a safety plan, which was implemented following her recording of a video threatening self-harm while with her child, A.C. The mother admitted that her mental health and substance abuse issues impaired her parenting, and she was adjudicated as an abusing parent. She was granted a post-adjudicatory improvement period. Subsequently, she entered into an agreement acknowledging her inability to provide adequately for A.C. at that time, which led to a dispositional order awarding full custody of A.C. to her non-abusing father, while her parental rights remained intact. The circuit court ordered the parties to return one year later for a modification hearing.After a year, the Department of Human Services filed a motion to modify the disposition and requested termination of the mother’s parental rights. At the modification hearing, witnesses, including the father and a child protective services worker, testified. The father reported an incident involving suspected drug paraphernalia but also stated he had never suspected the mother was under the influence during visits. The CPS worker testified that nothing had changed with the mother since the initial disposition. The circuit court nevertheless found a material change of circumstances and terminated the mother’s parental rights.On appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, the mother argued the Department failed to prove a material change in circumstances, as required by statute, and challenged the circuit court’s informal policy mandating a one-year limit on the dispositional order. The Department conceded that no material change had been alleged or proven and confessed error. The Supreme Court of Appeals held that the circuit court erred by terminating parental rights absent proof of a material change in circumstances and found the circuit court’s policy lacked statutory support and improperly shifted the burden. The order terminating parental rights was reversed and the case remanded for entry of an amended dispositional order. View "In re A.C." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia